Love of the Game February 2, 2013 Auction
Search By:
This lot is closed for bidding. Bidding ended on 2/3/2013
A very interesting type of 1910-era collectible are the die-cut, sepia-toned souvenir fans that feature images of the 16 captains of their various teams.  These fans, printed on heavy paper, also included blank scorecards and were affixed by staple to a wooden handle.  The fans that were used commercially also contained printed advertisements on the reverse, typically for local businesses.  

The fan contains images of the team captains, some of the most popular players of the day, including Germany Schaeffer, Bobby Wallace (HOF), Billy Sullivan, Hal Chase, George Moriarty, Harry Lord, Harry Davis, Nap Lajoie (HOF), Mickey Doolin (misspelled), Calvin Griffith (HOF), Bill Dahlen, Bill Sweeney, Frank Chance (HOF), Art Devlin, Fred Clarke (HOF, misspelled), and Roger Bresnahan (HOF).

This particular piece has never been used, no wooden handle has ever been stapled to it and local advertising has never been "crash printed" on the reverse (thus the reverse is simply blank).  It gives us a window into how these pieces were produced - it is not likely a proof, since it has been die cut already and clearly was intended for use.  However, this particular piece never got that far, as it was never circulated.  We have seen pieces with single business advertised on the reverse, and also with multiple businesses - clearly, local teams were able to sell space on the reverse of the fans, which would then be distributed to people as they entered the ballpark.  We have seen these printed in color, without the scorecard in the center, and also scored with dates as late as 1914.  Clearly, these were printed in quantity and used over an extended period.

This particular example is unused, unscored, with no advertising printed on the reverse and no handle.  Obviously used as a sample at some point in the production process, it has been preserved in outstanding condition, with very little wear.  Rarely will you see a piece as remarkably well-preserved as this.  The surface is outstanding, with virtually no wear.  The edges exhibit very mild fading to the color, and only very mild wear to the edges themselves.  All the die cuts are intact, with no chipping or missing pieces that are common with die-cut fans like this.  The reverse is clean and unprinted, with light toning consistent with its age.

In 1910, this was a dual-use piece: it was intended to be used to keep spectators cool during the game, and it was intended to serve as a game scorecard.  As a result, these are typically found with writing, tears, staples, tape, significant edge wear, broken handles, and more.  This is a relatively pristine example.  An amazing relic, in incredible condition, featuring multiple Hall of Famers.
Circa 1910 Baseball Team Captains Scorecard Fan unused sample w/HOFersCirca 1910 Baseball Team Captains Scorecard Fan unused sample w/HOFers
Circa 1910 Baseball Team Captains Scorecard Fan unused sample w/HOFers
Click above for larger image.
Current Bidding
Minimum Bid: $500
Final prices include buyers premium.: $649
Number Bids: 2
Auction closed on Sunday, February 3, 2013.
Email A Friend
Ask a Question
Have One To Sell

Auction Notepad


You may add/edit a note for this item or view the notepad:  

Submit    Delete     View all notepad items